If you want to level up your backyard BBQ game, nothing beats a grilled tomahawk steak.
This giant bone-in ribeye is the ultimate showstopper: impressive presentation, rich marbling, juicy buttery flavor, and that iconic long bone that makes every meal feel like a fine-dining feast. A lot of home grillers shy away from tomahawk steaks because of their thickness, worried they’ll end up with a burnt exterior and raw center.
But here’s the secret: you don’t need professional chef skills. The reverse sear method is foolproof for thick-cut steaks, and I’m breaking down every step today so you can grill a flawless tomahawk every single time.
Why Reverse Sear Is Best for Tomahawk Steak
Regular high-heat grilling works for thin steaks, but tomahawks are 2–3 inches thick and weigh 2–4 pounds. Blasting them on high heat right away ruins the texture.
Low-and-slow first, hot-sear second ensures even cooking from edge to center, locking in juice while building that crispy, golden brown Maillard crust we all crave. It’s the exact method steakhouses use for perfect thick-cut steaks.
What You’ll Need (Simple & Minimal)
Ingredients
-
1 Tomahawk steak (2–4 lbs, fresh prime or choice grade recommended)
-
Coarse kosher salt & freshly cracked black pepper (the only essential seasonings)
-
Unsalted butter, fresh rosemary, fresh thyme, garlic cloves (for herb basting)
Tools
-
Instant-read meat thermometer (non-negotiable for perfect doneness)
-
Grill tongs (never use forks!)
-
Aluminum foil
Step 1: Prep the Steak for Maximum Juiciness
Bring it to room temperature
Take your tomahawk out of the fridge 1.5 to 2 hours before grilling. Cold thick meat cooks extremely unevenly. Room-temperature steak guarantees consistent cooking all the way through.
Once rested, pat the steak completely dry with paper towels. Dry surfaces create a crispy sear—moisture equals steamed, bland steak.
Season generously
Salt every single side, including the fat cap and bone edges. Follow with fresh black pepper. For extra depth, add a light sprinkle of garlic powder or smoked paprika.
Let it sit for 30 minutes. The salt will draw out surface moisture, then reabsorb it, seasoning the meat deeply and locking in juiciness.
Make the herb butter baste (game-changer!)
Melt half a cup of unsalted butter in a small pan, add 3 crushed garlic cloves, a sprig of rosemary and thyme. Simmer gently until fragrant, then set aside for basting while searing.
Step 2: Set Up Your Grill for 2-Zone Heat
This is the most important grill setup for thick steak success.
-
Indirect low heat side: 250–300°F (for slow cooking the interior)
-
Direct high heat side: 500–550°F (for final searing and crust building)
Clean your grill grates and lightly oil them to prevent sticking. Charcoal grills add amazing smoky flavor, but gas grills work perfectly for beginner-friendly results.
Step 3: Slow Cook on Indirect Heat (Reverse Sear Base)
Place your tomahawk on the cool indirect side, bone-side down, and close the lid. No flipping needed during this stage!
Cook slowly until the internal temperature reaches 105–110°F (rare baseline):
-
2.5 lb steak: 30–40 minutes
-
3.5–4 lb steak: 45–60 minutes
Pro tip: Insert your thermometer into the thickest part of the steak, avoiding bone, for an accurate reading. This slow cook renders fat gently and cooks the steak evenly without drying it out.
Step 4: High-Heat Sear for Crispy Crust
Now it’s time for that iconic restaurant-style crust. Move the steak to the high-heat direct grates.
-
Sear 2–3 minutes per side, rotating every 60 seconds for even browning
-
Stand the steak on its fat edge and sear 1–2 minutes to render excess fat
-
Baste continuously with your garlic herb butter while searing
Stop searing once you hit your target internal temperature:
-
Rare: 120–125°F
-
Medium-Rare (best for tomahawk): 130–135°F
-
Medium: 140–145°F
Step 5: Rest the Steak (Do NOT Skip This!)
Transfer the grilled tomahawk to a cutting board, tent loosely with aluminum foil, and let it rest for 10–15 minutes.
Thick steaks hold massive heat. While resting, the juices redistribute back into the meat fibers, and the internal temperature rises an extra 5–10°F naturally. Skipping this step leads to dry, juice-poor steak every time.
Serving & Plating Tips
Slice the steak against the grain into thick, juicy strips, leaving the bone intact for a stunning presentation. Pair it with grilled asparagus, loaded baked potatoes, red wine reduction, or horseradish cream to balance the rich beef flavor.
This steak alone turns a regular backyard BBQ into a gourmet dinner party.
Pro Grilling Hacks for Perfect Results
-
Only use tongs to move the steak—forks pierce meat and leak precious juice
-
Shift the steak to indirect heat if heavy flare-ups occur
-
Add hickory or oak wood chips during slow cooking for extra smoky restaurant flavor
-
Never cut the steak early—patience equals juiciness
Final Thoughts
Grilling a tomahawk steak isn’t reserved for professional chefs. With the reverse sear method, anyone can pull off a tender, juicy, perfectly caramelized tomahawk steak at home.
It’s hands down the best steak to impress guests, elevate date night, or treat yourself to an incredible home-cooked feast. Follow these steps, and you’ll never have a dry or uneven tomahawk again!
){kind=link}